Saturday, December 24, 2011

Veg Out

I’ve always said, well, maybe not always, but recently, that there are three topics that can always start an argument: What god you believe in (or don’t), what political party you vote for, and what foods you eat (specifically meat eaters versus vegetarians).
For some reason, when people learn that I’m vegan, one of two statements follows: “Where do you get your protein?” or “Yeah, gee, you know, I don’t really eat that much meat.” I find both amusing for very different reasons. The protein thing is funny because I used to be one of those people asking that very question of my vegan friend twelve years ago. Once I got educated (or VEGucated, if you will. Okay, I stole that from Marisa Miller Wolfson.), I realized how silly the question is. A lot of mammals are herbivores. Think of cows. They weigh hundreds of pounds. Clearly, they get everything they need from plant foods. At least they would if they were allowed to graze on actual grass and not confined to dirty feedlots, eating a soy bean and corn diet, or worse, the brains of dead friends. (Hello, Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy? One order of Mad Cow Disease, please.).
It seems so obvious now, but for a long time I was clueless. Self-imposed stupidity. Sometimes it is easier to bury your head in the sand than acknowledge what is really going on and changing your habits, especially when it comes to factory farming and slaughterhouses. I avoided those images for a very long time. It’s easy to convince yourself that it’s not really happening or that it’s just that one slaughterhouse. There’s something disconnected about the way we view the food on our plates and the animals on a farm. We use creative words to describe things in a way that makes them easier to eat – chop, crispy, bacon, steak, drumstick. We learn as kids to place cows, pigs, and chickens in one category; dogs, cats, horses in another. One group we eat and wear, the others we don’t.
The “I don’t eat much meat” statement is obviously a knee-jerk reaction to my eating no animals. The funny part is when they start listing all the “not much meat” they actually eat. “I eat a burger every once in a while, you know, maybe once or twice a week. Fish, too, but just salmon. And shrimp – are they considered fish? Oh, and crab. I love crab. Chicken, but just a couple of times a week. But that’s about it. Oh, and bacon. I loooooove bacon. Who doesn’t love bacon, right? The Divine Swine……” It’s usually around this point that their voice trails off and they stop talking and the awkward silence settles in until someone clears their throat and starts talking about something neutral, like the war in Iraq.
There is something freeing about living your values. I like knowing that something hasn’t died for my appetite. I attended a dinner recently for a local dog and cat rescue. There wasn’t one vegetarian, let alone vegan, item on the menu. When I mentioned it to one of the organizers, she just looked at me with a confused expression on her face. I asked her if she thought it was odd that we’re trying to save one animal while eating another. She didn’t. “Cows and chickens don’t live in our homes, so why should we try to rescue them?” Um, well, I wasn’t suggesting that we should go out and rescue all of them necessarily, just not serve them at a benefit for animals. It’d be like wearing leather at an anti-fur rally. She wasn’t getting it and made a hasty exit, far, far away from me.
People get defensive for no apparent reason. It is odd how a simple acknowledgment, like “I’m vegan,” causes people to get their backs up and feel the need to explain (justify?) their eating habits. I got into a heated debate (argument really) with a good friend over this very issue. The most unfortunate part of the conversation was that it took place in my car in the middle of a long, five-hour drive. You can’t really go anywhere in a Prius, even if you’re not speeding down the highway. Our “discussion” centered around milk and cheese and how she could “never give up cheese” and “what’s the big deal anyway?” it’s just milk and it’s not like any cows die or anything, right? Um…. well, no!!! When I started to explain that dairy cows are repeatedly impregnated and male calves are sold for veal, she emptied both barrels. Her reaction was damn near nuclear. 
Talking to her, with her in that state, was next to impossible. She was throwing out wild assertions like “dairy cows aren’t slaughtered for meat” and “cows can lactate for three years.” I kept repeating “that’s not true,” which only made her scream, “IT IS TRUE!” Even when I reminded her of a meat recall in California in which downed dairy cows made it into the human food supply as hamburger for the school lunch program and the fact that we humans (mammals, like cows) can’t lactate for three years unless we become pregnant again, she kept on yelling that I was wrong.  
She then accused me of having an agenda. An agenda? Yes, a (gasp!) vegan agenda to make everyone stop eating animals. “It’s impossible!!” She shrieked. Her suggestion was to make their life “better” before we murder them. Oh, great idea. Who defines “better?” Us or the animals? I’m thinking the pig has a vested interest in how that conversation goes. As for an agenda, I don’t have one, but if I did, stopping the senseless deaths of 100 billion animals worldwide each year sounds like a pretty awesome agenda to have. Sign. Me. Up! Second, I don’t expect Eskimos, living on a frozen tundra, to grow broccoli and make tofu. I’m not an idiot. Third, what about the “agenda” of the meat, dairy, and egg industries? How many “happy asparagus” commercials do you see on TV? How many “Got hummus” mustaches adorn the upper lip of celebrities in magazines? When have you ever seen, “Tofu. It’s what’s for dinner,” on a billboard? Yeah. My big agenda. Hold on while I get the Kale lobbyist on the phone. Oh, that’s right. There isn’t one.
I still talk about veganism (clearly). I “bake and release” as I like to call it (keeps me from Hoovering up a dozen cupcakes and I can dispel myths about vegan foods). I share news stories about animal abuse and factory farms with friends on Facebook. I espouse the health benefits whenever nutrition comes up. Occasionally, I pick fights with people wearing T-shirts that say, “I like animals… on my plate.” I challenge the idea that dogs and cats are the only animals that shouldn’t be slaughtered. There are, of course, some people that you just can’t reach. People who raise animals and then kill them will not be moved to change based on compassion. 
We each have our own path in life and have to follow our inner ethical compass. For me, that means living as compassionate a life as possible. Am I perfect? Hardly. But, as the brilliant activist and author Colleen Patrick-Goudreau said, “Don’t do nothing because you can’t do everything. Do something. Anything.” This is my anything.

4 comments:

  1. I honestly will never understand our(human beings) inability to simply accept and respect other peoples opinions, values, and beliefs.
    I know many would say bullshit to me thinking its not possible when I told them I am perfectly comfortable with people who believe completely different than I. Liberal vs conservative...relgious vs nonreligious...and vegan vs not (I had never even thought that this would be a relationship causing friction, but I would never be disrespectful to any of my vegan friends or family).
    I am a strong and opinionated woman but I also have respect, empathy, and understadning for others. As long as the devout christian isn't trying to convert me or my opposing political views aren't trying to change my thinking by telling me I am just wrong (citing talk show hosts will never help), but oddly I don't think I would be upset with my vegan friends and family trying to convert me (and my family). The motivation behind wanting a friend or family member to eat in a way that is health and earth friendly...how can that be considered negative?
    I will continue to read and follow Renee...I look forward to your thoughts and help to get us all to see past what corporations want us to see.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for sharing your blog with me, but I'm a little confused at your use of me as an example of "someone who cannot be reached." I was not aware that this is how family treats one another. While my lifestyle may not set well with you, I have tried very hard to accomodate your food choices on the few times you have ate in our home. I fully take responsiblity for not being educated in the "vegan" ways of "chicken stock," but I have been more than open to hearing about eating less meat via watching the video you sent here and reading the cookbooks that you've recommended. I find your comments toward me harsh. You have a wealth of information to share with others, you are very passionate about your eating choices. . .remember you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Gandhi said "Be the change you want to see in the world." I believe this is the only way to change the world and to change people, by serving as a good example for others. Renee you have a clear life purpose which is serving animals, it is obvious to anyone who meets you that this is what you are passionate about. Because of your passion, I am sure that you want others to feel the same way, however not everyone is on the same life path. Most compassionate people want to end the suffering of humans and animals on this planet, however refraining from a diet of meat that has been a staple for hundreds of years is not an easy task and not high on people list of daily chores, especially when so many are just trying to survive by whatever means possible. Most people adapt a vegan lifestyle as part of wanting to eliminate meat for health reasons or because they are on a path to spiritual enlightenment. As you are an Atheist, I find it interesting that you have such compassion for animals without acknowledging that humans and animals have a soul. Your human soul connecting with their animal soul is what compels you to feel such empathy for them. Every human being feels it, some more so than others. You could say that is a "belief" that I hold that may not be true for you, but I don't know how else to explain it. I think that your high level of empathy is both a blessing and a curse. It gives you a clear life purpose of trying to end suffering, but also causes you to unintentionally alienate yourself from the people who you care about and who care the most about you. I hope you keep writing about what you are passionate about and keep being yourself!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't expect everyone to be on the same path as me nor is it my intention to alienate anyone. If someone feels alienated by my pointing out the inconsistencies of our thought process regarding which animals we eat, love, and wear, that is on them, not me. If someone attacks me unprovoked, as what happened in my car (with obvious literary embellishments), I am going to stand up for my beliefs. It was a vicious attack, from my point of view, which I re-told with some intentional sarcasm and humor to lighten what is a very painful memory for me.

    Not everyone can be reached with an argument based on compassion. People know what happens on factory farms. People know animals are mistreated and murdered for our appetites. And yet, they continue to buy meat from the grocery store, or raise and kill their own animals. I was one of those people, which I pointed out. I lived under a veil and buried my head until someone else planted a seed and opened my eyes because they spoke their truth.

    I'm no one's role model and it is not my goal to convert anyone or force people to believe what I do... only to challenge the status quo and get people talking, which evidently has worked and underscores my opening line that the three topics that get people talking are politics, religion, and food.

    Veganism, for me, is not about spiritual enlightenment, it's about not contributing to the suffering of another living being and causing its death. I don't believe you have to believe in God or souls in order to be compassionate. I think that says more about who we are innately than about a higher power. The fact that people can be compassionate towards others without the belief in rewards in an afterlife is a testament to human nature and our inherent goodness. Animals have the same ability to empathize and love their young and their mates the same way we do without the intellectual understanding. It's instinctual and has nothing to do with religion or God.

    Thank you for understanding that my intention is simply to speak my truth, even when it's ugly and harsh, and not to hurt or force others to believe what I do.

    ReplyDelete